MUMBAI / NEW DELHI: It was too good to last. The "truce" reached last month (14 December) between sports broadcaster ESPN Star Sports and Hinduja group MSO InCableNet looks all set to unravel in Mumbai and possibly in other centres as well.

And for the avid cricket lover, the timing couldn't have been worse. The Indian cricket team's magnificent performance in the ongoing test series with Australia would only have vetted the viewers' appetites for the one-day spectacle that is to follow.

For the record, ESS shot off a missive to InCableNet yesterday, asserting that the agreement that was in place had become invalid as off 31 December. The letter set a deadline of 5 pm today for InCableNet to revert on the matter. The letter holds out the threat that if the MSO failed to respond, ESS would be free "to take all necessary and relevant steps" (read shut-off).

InCableNet on its part sent off a reply asserting that since a meeting to discuss this very matter had already been scheduled for the 5th in Mumbai, it did not understand the purpose of the letter issued by ESS. InCableNet has further stated that as per the understanding reached between the two parties on 14 December, disconnection requires seven days prior intimation.

InCableNet also covered old ground in its response regarding the difficulties it was facing in raising monies from the ground:

*The MSO's declared base to ESS in Mumbai exceeds its paid connectivity.

*Consumer resistance to increasing pay TV rates continues to be a strong disincentive to increasing rates.

*ESS' "best rates and favourable terms" imply an increase of monthly pay outs by 36 to 40 per cent and with substantial upfront payments

Sricharan Iyengar, V-P affiliate sales ESPN Software had this to say about the looming face-off: "If the Hindujas don't come back to us within the given deadline, then we would have no option but to switch them off." He however clarified that at the moment both the parties were talking about the Mumbai market only, adding, "If the Hindujas don't want to renegotiate for Mumbai, then we'd presume they won't like to do for other markets too. The onus is on them."

According to Iyengar, "The problem here is that the Hindujas are insisting on paying us according to the old rates that were signed two years back. Things have changed since 2001 and we would like to renegotiate, which they are not willing to do."

"We had given them very attractive offers, including a variety of tariff plans, but they are not willing to negotiate. This stance is certainly not acceptable to us. They have come back to us on certain things, but they are actually non-proposals and bizarre."

Iyengar further stated, "It is strange that the Hindujas neither want to accept the increased subscription rates (Rs 39.70), nor do they want to go in for an increase in the declared subscriber base. Their plea is that the company cannot pay anything more as they themselves get paid a certain amount. If the Hindujas want to give the ESS feed free to their distributors, it's their problem, not ours. Why should we sacrifice our revenues for such subsidisation?"

Looks like the first major face-off of the year between the cable fraternity and the pay broadcasters will be played out between "regular antagonists" ESS and InCableNet. And with the other pay broadcasters expected to make their own announcements of subscription rate hikes, expect more such face-offs to surface in the near future.